The Best Boutique Hotels in Niagara-on-the-Lake (High-End, Refined & Highly Rated)

Niagara-on-the-Lake has long been known for its wineries, historic streets, theatre culture, and slow, romantic pace. But where you stay here matters. A great hotel doesn’t just give you a place to sleep — it sets the tone for your entire visit.

If you’re looking for truly high-end, boutique accommodations in Niagara-on-the-Lake, these are the two standout properties that consistently rise to the top for design, service, and guest satisfaction.

124 on Queen Hotel & Spa

For Modern Boutique Luxury, Spa Lovers & Walkable Wine Country

124 on Queen is one of the most refined and consistently highly rated boutique hotels in Niagara-on-the-Lake. Located directly on Queen Street, it offers a rare combination of modern luxury, full spa amenities, and true walkability to Old Town shops, restaurants, and wineries.

What makes it special is how seamlessly it blends contemporary design with small-town charm. The rooms and suites are spacious, beautifully finished, and feel intentionally calm rather than overtly flashy. The on-site spa is a destination in itself, with hydrotherapy pools, thermal circuits, and treatment rooms that rival much larger resort properties.

Guests who choose 124 on Queen are usually looking for a spa-forward wine country escape, walkable access to Old Town, modern comfort without sacrificing intimacy, and high design paired with reliable, high-touch service.

It’s a perfect choice for romantic weekends, wellness-driven escapes, and travellers who value polish, privacy, and convenience in equal measure.

Best for: Spa lovers, couples, refined luxury seekers, walkable stays

The Scotsman Hotel

For Design Purists, Total Privacy & Boutique Exclusivity

The Scotsman Hotel is at the opposite end of the boutique spectrum — intentionally small, highly curated, and deeply design-driven. With only a handful of suites, it offers a level of privacy and personalization that larger hotels simply can’t match.

This is the kind of place that attracts designers, architects, creatives, and travellers who value distinctiveness over scale. Every space within The Scotsman feels deliberate — from the materials chosen to the way light moves through the rooms. The atmosphere is quiet, intimate, and effortlessly refined.

Guests who stay here often describe the experience as calm, restorative, deeply personal, and refreshingly understated.

If you want your stay to feel like a private residence rather than a hotel, The Scotsman is an exceptional choice.

Best for: Design lovers, couples seeking seclusion, intimate luxury, slow travel

Choosing Between the Two

These are both exceptional boutique hotels — but they offer very different experiences.

If you want full spa facilities, walkability, and the buzz of town life, 124 on Queen is the perfect match.

If you want ultra-private accommodation, a design-led, residential feel, and total quiet and discretion, The Scotsman Hotel will feel like home.

You truly can’t make a wrong choice — it simply comes down to how you want your Niagara-on-the-Lake story to unfold.

From Niagara-on-the-Lake to Caledon

Many of our guests at The Liberty Inn plan their travels around small, independently run, design-forward hotels across Ontario — places where the owner’s care is felt in the details.

If your next getaway brings you toward the rolling hills of Caledon, the Forks of the Credit, forest trails, and quiet spa evenings, we’d love to welcome you to The Liberty Inn — a five-suite boutique retreat built with the same commitment to craftsmanship, calm, and connection.